“Thanks.”
He shook his head. “The media are outside. Got their attention, in the end. Fancy talking to them?”
Ruth looked at Anna, who shrugged. “Your decision.”
“For the sake of dealing with questions,” Karen added from beside Tom, “you’re still in post and Richard’s resigned. It’s complicated, if they’re pushy with questions about that say you’re unable to comment at this stage. Stick to social justice and condemning the treatment of the camp residents and all that. That’ll give you quite enough to say. Also, the people love their rebel Archbishop, so work it.”
Ruth rubbed her forehead. “Um… right. I guess I’ll do that. It’s… I’d kind of like to know what’s going on.”
“Well the rest of us would like to know when you’re going to get yourself arrested, so you can hardly complain.”
“Valid.”
Karen shrugged. “It’s paying off. Protests outside Parliament, illicit charity ventures springing up everywhere. Even a tweet from the Pope about the need for Christians to stand up against governments for the sake of those being persecuted, or something like that. I know he posts that kind of stuff a lot, but this felt very much connected to our antics.”
“That’s something, then.” She let Karen straighten her coat collar. “Right, let’s get on with it, then one of you can tell me what the hell is going on with Richard…”
She stepped out into a barrage of flashes and marched straight down the steps towards the barriers, suppressing concerns about what’s happened in the past twenty-four hours. Right to the fence, to scan the logos on the microphones, Karen’s hand on her back guiding her in the right direction, holding herself together by force of will. Cameras and microphones in her face, a barrage of questions until she held up her hands for quiet.
“When the law does not serve the people, it is not worthy of being called a law. When it is not just, it is not worthy of being called the justice system. A legal system that allows armed police to drive out people whose only crime is to be homeless, not even from a street or an abandoned building but from a plot of empty land, a government which beyond not caring for those in need, tells them they are not allowed to exist. The government has to remember that it is accountable to the people. The police have to remember that their job is to protect, not to persecute.
“When the decision was made to dissolve the camp, it was made quietly. The police arrived without warning and ordered the people to leave, people who have wintered there for four months, who have built communities and found some poor approximation of certainty. They arrested many of the volunteers who have been feeding these people for three months, who have kept them alive when the government decided not to bother. Is helping people illegal now? If it is, then we should all be breaking the law. Don’t sit back, make them answer the atrocities which they have committed.
“The people being persecuted are human beings. Talk to any of them and you’ll discover a story, probably of hard work and misfortune. Are you going to blame cancer survivors because they sold their homes to afford treatment? Or single mothers who lost their jobs when the companies they worked for closed down, and then couldn’t find anything else that would make ends meet? Teenagers running away from abusive families? What have they done, that they don’t even deserve a tent in a muddy field, that police can come without warning and tear away their lives? Apparently it’s illegal for anyone to help them. Apparently we’re all supposed to turn our faces away and ignore them as they die of starvation, cholera, and hypothermia. I don’t know about anyone else, but that’s not something I’m willing to do, and if that’s illegal,” she shrugged expansively, “see you in court.”
She turned and strode away towards the car, dashing tears away impatiently with the back of her hand. Fuck it, she wanted to say. Fuck the people who thought that some humans were more valuable than others. Who thought death only mattered if the deceased had money. She could see the faces in her head, hear their stories, a clamour that left no room for thought.
They piled into the car, Karen in the back seat beside her. She stared through the tinted windows as Tom pulled out, then fumbled through her bag for a clean tissue. She could still see the camera flashes when she blinked, and her arms seemed to tingle where police officers had taken hold of her. It had been a long couple of days, way too much to process. She just had to hold herself together.
“What the fuck happened with Richard?”
The other three looked at each other, and then Tom sighed and answered.
“He announced his resignation that afternoon. Said that he was sorry he’d taken so long to act, that he was proud of the way the Church was going, that it was time for for him to hand over to... basically, someone better suited to lead in this context. Words to that effect, anyway.”
“That’s a new tack. I mean, I know he’d changed his attitudes a bit, but…”
“The Church of England is moving whether he likes it or not,” Tom interrupted. “I told you what he said, but you know what's really happening.”
She squeezed her head in her hands, trying to get her thoughts straight. “So he... doesn't actually want to go? Sorry, I... it's been a long couple of days.”
“Nobody pushed him. But the Archbishop of Canterbury can’t just decide to ignore the Clergy Discipline Measure, and you’ve already been rebuked for the same thing two months ago. Especially given his attitudes a few months ago, it would have been a massive U-turn for him, and one which would have gone against his duty as Archbishop – which includes a responsibility for discipline.”
“Oh.”
Tom glanced at her in the wing mirror. “General consensus is you have lived according to Christian teaching, so it would be wrong for the Church to take action as a result. No bishops are willing to suspend you – Lizzie openly refused, she’s willing to do that in a way that Richard wasn’t. And even without the moral side, the Church of England does not like the idea of being two Archbishops down, particularly not in the current climate. And particularly not when everyone’s running around frantically trying to cover the sudden loss of the Archbishop of Canterbury.”
“Ah. So… Richard resigned so I could stay.”
“Not explicitly, but essentially yes.”
“Oh.” She stared out of the window. Richard was calm, level-headed, a good politician and an excellent person to have at the head of the Church of England. He kept things running smoothly, made sure everything was properly considered, provided stability when the Church was facing crises. She was passionate and unpredictable, not what they needed at all.
“We’re going to Lambeth now, so you can meet Richard,” Tom told her. “Obviously a vacancy in Canterbury means there’s stuff you’ll need to know. Eucharist first, obviously.”
“And then you and I are going to go through what you’re saying on Newsnight tonight,” added Karen.
Of course she had a TV interview. Just go along with it.
“Has Richard gone already, or just said he's going?”
“He’s staying until the end of the month. They’re rather frantically organising a farewell service in Canterbury for his last Sunday.”
“That’s… not long.”
“Nope, but any longer and he’d actually have to tie up the loose ends.”
“I’ve really screwed things up this time, haven’t I?”
“You could say that.”
“But a lot of people wouldn’t,” added Karen, not looking up from her phone.
It was awkward, going through Lambeth Palace after the events of the past twenty-four hours. Getting strange looks, some admiring, others hostile. These were Richard’s people, after all. She’d turned their lives upside down.
And Richard himself, a half smile pushing at the corners of his lips, the bags under his eyes even more pronounced than usual. He waved her over after the service with a tired gesture, saying no more than five words until they were in private.
“Well. I’m not going to criticise.”
“Sorry.”
“Thank you. It’s my fault as much as anyone’s, for failing to read the signs, not predicting how this would develop. Anyway, it’s probably just as well I step back, I’m not the right kind of person to lead the Church in this direction – and it's going in this direction, whatever I do. You were right, of course, it is our duty as Christians to care. This isn’t the way I’d have chosen to do it – the Anglican Communion is a complex, fragile thing – but what’s done is done and if it doesn’t break it we might just end up with something stronger. I don’t envy my successor, though.”
She shook her head. “Nor do I. There’s been so much shaking, I’d almost be surprised if we don’t need a restructure, or at least for revision in some core areas. Admittedly, it’s probably overdue anyway, you can’t run an organisation on the same lines for more than a hundred years, in a shifting environment…”
“You started out in management, didn’t you?”
“Sorry.”
“It’s not necessarily a bad thing, as I remember you telling me. You know you’re probably going to get asked?”
She frowned in confusion, and then snorted. “Unlikely. I think they’ll want someone with self control.”
“You could hardly be accused of incompetence.”
She shook her head, considering the idea. “There is no way in… heaven, hell, or anywhere in between, that I am taking the job. It’d be a terrible idea. And is very much not my calling. Even if it wasn’t too restrictive for me, I’m too old for that.”
He shrugged. “Fair enough. It’s quite a job, if it’s your vocation, but I can’t say it’s a step towards retirement. Funny, how the busiest jobs always go to the people with the least energy! Well, someone will be found – I can think of a few possibilities, it’ll be very interesting to see who the Crown Nominations Commission decide on, what they decide the Church needs in my successor. But there’ll be something of a gap before then, especially as I’m leaving so suddenly, and we should talk about that. Archbishops’ Council emergency meeting on Friday, after that I hand over to you. Good luck…”
“Um, thanks?” She supposed it was her fault anyway.
“My team here will be getting in touch with yours at Bishopthorpe, passing a few things over. Easter address broadcasts and all that, you know. You’d better have a good team.”
“Wonderful. Though I’ve just appointed a new chaplain, we’ll announce it as soon as we get time…”
“Oh yes, you’re replacing Tom, aren’t you? Shame, you two seem to make a good pair. It’s not the best moment for it…”
“Don’t remind me! Right, any details to go through?”
They talked details for the next hour, before finally getting up to move on with their different days.
“Well, I’ll see you in a few days, then. I believe Kath did some diary rearranging for you, so it’s all clear for Archbishops’ Council…”
“I’ll see you there. And really, I’m sorry, about all of this.”
He shrugged, looking at his phone. “We’re all just trying to do the right thing.”
We’re all just trying to do the right thing. The words stayed with her, later, as she tried to concentrate on an overflowing email account. They were all trying, but for some people it didn’t pay off. What was the right thing, anyway?
Dear Lucy,
I’m very sorry but I will have to rearrange our meeting on Friday. Would you be able to come to Bishopthorpe at either 7.30pm on Thursday or 9am on Saturday? I know that these times are inconvenient, if neither is suitable then please liaise with my chaplain. Unfortunately I’m unlikely to have another space in my diary until a week on Monday at the earliest, as I will be out of York, though I know that it would be best for you to have this resolved as soon as possible. Let me know.
With prayers and warmest wishes,
+Ruth
Poor Lucy. Ruth took a moment to pray for her, as she’d promised. The deacon’s problems might be small compared to everything else Ruth was dealing with right now, but as far as Lucy was concerned it was her entire life in question. Everything seemed critical when you were a curate, at least from Ruth’s experience.
The reply was quick in coming.
Dear Archbishop,
9am on Saturday would be fine. Thank you for making time, I know you are very busy at the moment.
Lucy
Ruth smiled sadly as she put it in her diary. Lucy’s early emails had been so formal, painstakingly reworded until they took a second read-through to pick out the useful content. It was good that she’d given up on that, but also a sign of just how much had gone wrong, how much communication had gone between the two of them. Ruth could have left Tom or Kath to do the rearranging for her, but it was only a few seconds to type out an email, and hopefully it would make Lucy feel more valued. Heaven knows she needed that.
Dear Lucy,
Thank you for your swift response, I look forward to seeing you. As it is Saturday morning we have Communion at 8.20 following Morning Prayer at 8am, it is possible that this will overrun and make me a few minutes late, and that no one will be around to meet you. If this is the case, just make yourself comfortable in reception until we emerge. You are of course welcome at one or both of the services, but it is very early to be coming out, and I expect that you have more use for an extra hour of sleep.
God bless,
+Ruth
She sent it, sighed, and carried on through her diary. Everything else on Friday could be rearranged by Tom or Kath, and she sent them both an email to that effect. What else wanted her attention? Invitations to speak at Holy Week and Easter events. Event launch details from the Minster to be glanced through and then ignored. News of the death of a retired bishop, aged ninety six. An unnecessary volume of stuff relating to the consecration on Tuesday. Something felt off, inside, and she couldn't settle, her mind refusing to stick to a task for more than a few seconds at a time, everything taking longer than it should. She was most of the way through when Karen appeared, and the focus turned to media.
A strange week, definitely. Dozing in the car after the Newsnight interview on the long drive back up to York, only to catch a train down again on Friday morning and back that evening. Plenty of time on the train to dash off a confirmation sermon and work on what to say at Rachel’s consecration, and then to go through a veritable mountain of stuff connected to Archbishops’ Council and the formation of the Crown Nominations Commission - there was definitely a reason she travelled first class, even if she sometimes felt guilty for it. Then Friday night, getting back relatively early, looking at the unassailable stack of work to be done and deciding instead to return to the first of the books she was attempting to read for Lent. Taking the book to bed and falling asleep, waking up when it dropped onto her face, taking that as the signal to go to bed properly.
She stifled a yawn as she stepped out at the end of Morning Prayer on Saturday to throw on stole and chasuble. Returning to find the skeleton congregation increased by the addition of a young, lost-looking figure, Ruth hesitated by the door as David, one of the part-time receptionists, helped Lucy to get settled.
After the service, she stripped off vestments quickly and handed them to Sr. Helena to deal with.
“Sorry to rush. Meeting.”
“Of course. Go.”
Ruth did so, throwing on her jacket as she went, to catch the last attendees drifting from the chapel.
“Lucy! Good to see you, come with me. Coffee?”
“Yes please.”
“I must say, dedication to have made the service…”
“I was awake so I thought…”
“I was very pleased to see you. Now, this is the staff kitchen… Saturday is quiet as you can tell. Milk, sugar?”
“Yes please.”
“There you go… Now, let’s go up to my office.”
A few minutes later, Lucy was installed in an armchair opposite Ruth, who had a small stack of papers on the table to one side and was flicking quickly through tabs on her tablet.
“Okay, excuse me while I get myself in order… so I’ve had several emails from Janice and Angela, about their meetings with you. They seem pleased with the plan, I just wanted to get you in and check it’s all okay before I sign it off. So, you’ve met your new training incumbent, any hesitations there before it all becomes formal?”
Lucy shook her head. “No, I like Tim. Though it’s not what I wanted, originally, it’ll be fine. Good experience.”
“Yes, I know it’s not quite your own tradition, and it’s rural, which you didn’t originally want. But Angela says here you’re happy to go for it. Is that right? Don’t be pushed into it if you’re not comfortable, it’ll just be more trouble in the long term…” Though if Lucy wasn’t happy with this one, she wouldn’t be getting a new curacy until the next batch started in the summer, and Ruth would have to revoke her license until then. As, no doubt, Lucy knew.
“Some of the churches are more my style, Tim says I can particularly focus on them. And rural ministry’s important too, there’s a lot going on. Anyway, something different won’t necessarily be a bad thing.”
“So long as you can have a good relationship with Tim, you’ll be okay. There are a lot of people for whom curacy doesn’t match up to expectations, but it’s still a learning process which gets you to where you need to be, and in fact from my own experience, a more difficult curacy can really help you to develop as a person and as a minister. Not that it’s ideal, but God finds good in everything. If I hadn’t learnt to deal with the conservative and sometimes deeply unpleasant attitudes to women’s ordination in my own curacy, for example, I would have been far more affected by the opposition to my appointment to this job. It’s also useful to understand and to be comfortable leading worship in all different traditions. For a start, because the state of the Church at present means you probably won’t be able to start out doing exactly the job you want – stipendiary positions are not that common, and a lot of them are like this curacy you’re going to, encompassing a wide range of churches in all different traditions, based simply on geographic location. You might find a charismatic church that suits you well, and the job also happens to include celebrating the Eucharist twice a week in a traditional church around the corner. We need priests who can lead both churches well, and this kind of willingness to look beyond your first choices will get you a long way.”
“I’m sure God has a reason, for all of this.”
“Hmm. That’s remarkably close to saying God has a reason for causing suffering.”
“I mean…”
“I know. For whatever reason it happens, we can recognise God’s presence with us in it, and God’s ability to use anything for good. So you’re happy with the curacy change? Any lingering concerns?”
“No… only, some of the churches, I’ve never really been in that kind of service before. Except a couple of times, when my DDO sent me. And kind of this morning. I mean, I’m used to communion, but not so… formal?”
How did they get through theological college without becoming used to that, Ruth wondered. “You’re worried about not being familiar enough with the worship style?”
Lucy nodded.
“That’s why you have a training incumbent. Tim will introduce you to it gently, make sure you’re comfortable with and understand everything. There’s a lot of richness in the tradition of the Church of England, I’m sure you’ll start to love it when you’re more used to it. Have you been to the Minster?”
“Well, ordination, obviously. And Night Out on Saturday quite a few times, and some of the other events, especially before Christmas, with Mark. And evensong, once.”
Ruth hesitated a moment. “Have you got anything on Tuesday afternoon?”
“Um, not until four, I don’t think. I was going to do admin. And since I’m about to leave…” she tailed off.
“How would you like to come to Rachel May’s consecration? Tickets are already distributed, so no promises, but I might be able to slip you in, if you don’t mind being tucked in a corner somewhere. If Mark were around, he’d have got you in, since he’s a canon. It’ll be full ceremonial – more than your ordination – and just really fun. And uplifting.”
“I… really?”
“Sure. It’s my cathedral, I get to make cheeky requests.”
“You’re busy, you don’t need any more trouble.”
“I make trouble for myself as a matter of course, it’s nothing. The offer's there if you want.”
“It’d be… amazing, I guess. Not something I ever thought about, but it must be awesome.”
“Oh, it will be, it's one of my favourite services - after the Triduum. I’ll drop a line to Stephen, ask him to find somewhere to squeeze you.” She smiled. “It’ll give you something to talk about. Which, I’ll admit, will probably be very welcome with all the questions you must be getting about the curacy shift.”
“It is a bit difficult. Especially not having any answers to give. Like all the questions of whether I’ll still be priested this summer… I mean…” she looked down awkwardly.
“Sure, that’s understandable, it’s horrible to be in a position where you don’t know, even if the strongest answer anyone can ever give is ‘God willing’. Barring unforeseen circumstances, though, yes I do expect for you to be ordained, if not at the start of Petertide then Michaelmas, a couple of months later. The exact timing being a matter for me to discuss with Angela and Tim in a few months, to work out what’s best for you.” She twisted her ring. “Is that… reassuring?”
“It’s good to know I haven’t screwed everything up completely.”
“For a start, it’s not your fault. Besides that, you’d be amazed just how few curacies run smoothly. I think I was crying about four times a week at one point, and I did at least have a training incumbent. It’s all about pulling yourself together before you next speak to someone. And a lot of sobbing over the phone to friends and ex-tutors. Not to mention on your spiritual director’s sofa.”
Lucy smiled slightly. “I’m seeing her next week. My spiritual director, I mean.”
“Good. You’ll need support through the transition. Ask all the really stupid questions; they’re actually perfectly reasonable, they just feel stupid.”
“It feels really weird… when you talk about your curacy. I mean… sorry…”
“No, I suppose so. We all started somewhere. It’s funny to think that thirty years ago, when I was at your stage, I had no idea I’d end up here - partly, of course, because it was still five years until the first woman was ordained bishop in the Church of England, but it was more than that. There was still a bit of me convinced it was all a massive mistake and I shouldn’t have been ordained at all. Now, of course, I’m more worried about messing up and nobody telling me. So yes, these fears are normal. Anyway, what I was meaning to say is yes, I remember it well, and no, I wasn’t miraculously more competent than anyone else. I once told a parishioner that if he didn’t feel he could receive from me that was his problem and not mine, he’d made me quite aware enough already and I would, whether he liked it or not, continue doing the job which the Church of England had concluded I had every right to do.” She shook her head. “My training incumbent told me off for calling it a right rather than a privilege, though I tried to argue the context of the remark. And for being disrespectful of the theological convictions of others. The parishioner stopped attending services at which I celebrated - which he might as well have done in the first place. In short, don’t worry that I’m going to judge you, I know just how easy it is to say the wrong thing.”
Lucy grinned. “I wish I had the courage to say stuff like that.”
“Well, I did have a few years of management experience from before ordination. But really, speaking your mind isn’t always the way to go, and if we all did it we’d never be able to live alongside one another. Society works because we’re different enough to coexist. Just be the best version of yourself you can be.” She glanced subtly at her watch. “So, curacy. Yours, not mine, mine’s long past. How are you feeling, anything else bothering you?”
Lucy looked at her hands, rolling a bracelet up and down her wrist. Oops, something Ruth had missed, hopefully she’d inadvertently unlocked it. Lucy glanced up nervously, and Ruth nodded reassurance.
“I’m… I keep feeling really angry, with Mark. Everything was going so well and then… he disappeared without a word, told me to do my best and that he believed in me and then he was off. Didn’t reply to emails or pick up the phone when… when everything was going wrong. And then I had to do it all myself and he could just… he could just have picked up the phone. I know he went to do good stuff but… I’m still angry… and I know I shouldn’t be… but it was perfect… sorry...”
Ruth sat forward. “You’re doing a brilliant job, Lucy. I know it doesn’t feel like it, but you are. Janice and Angela have emailed me, they’re impressed too – no, I’m not talking about the parish, I’m talking about how you’re handling yourself. Even just talking to me now, you’re being honest with me. You’re still determined to make it work, even though everything’s fallen apart. I’m amazed at the amount of grace with which you’re taking a new curacy which is so far from anything you’re comfortable with; I know you have the determination to make it work for you. And yes, it sucks right now, but it’ll be okay.”
Lucy used her free hand to brush impatiently at her eyes. “Sorry. I shouldn’t be so angry with him. I know why he went, I know I need to forgive him, I just… I keep on thinking I have then realising I haven’t. Sorry. There’s no reason I should have expected everything to stay perfect, but I still, like… sorry. I just… sorry.”
Ruth smiled. “You’re doing the apologising thing again.”
“Sorry. I mean…”
They both laughed, before Ruth turned serious again.
“Forgiveness isn’t easy. You can pray every day for the grace to forgive and still find it impossible, it can take years or decades and we need to accept that. Yes, we talk about it all the time, about loving our enemies and all that, but most of us don’t have enemies. The challenge is how to forgive our friends, when they hurt us, and that’s not as easy as it sounds at first. Which can make it really hard to pray “forgive us our sins as we forgive”, the only comfort is that God is much better at it than us, we just have to trust that God sees we’re trying. It’s also hard to forgive someone who isn’t even looking for our forgiveness, who perhaps doesn’t realise how much they’ve hurt us. If Mark were to come back today, would you welcome him, and be generous in spite of the hurt he’s caused you? I think you would, even if you had to hide your anger to do so. And if he asked for your forgiveness, I think you’d give it – if only he were to ask. But all this unfinished business, it is hard to move on from.”
“I keep expecting him to come back.”
“And disrupt everything just as it’s almost sorted? I’m not surprised. You should know that even if he does, the curacy change will go ahead, I’m about to sign it off. You’ve spent long enough in limbo.” Not to mention the fact that Mark would no longer be considered a suitable training minister, at least without significant further training and a several years of personal development, and then only if they were desperate. And there'd be the disciplinary actions in response to having disappeared for three months. Lucy didn’t need to think about that.
“That’s… good to know. Thanks.”
“If you’re worried about anything, ask, and chances are I can answer it and save you a lot of stress.”
“I’m sorry, I’m taking up so much of your time…”
“Keep doing it, I’d rather spend it on you than on opening fancy shopping centres. This is my vocation, not all the committee meetings and prancing around in a mitre.” Lucy laughed, and Ruth picked up a sheet of paper from beside her chair. “This is the fatal document. Any final comments, before I sign your life over to someone else?”
“Um, sorry for being pathetic and crying everywhere?”
“No, thank you for crying on me, and trusting me rather than trying to pretend everything’s okay. If you hadn’t broken down last time we met, I’d have assumed everything was fine, and let’s not imagine what state things would have been in by now if that were the case.” She found the signature box and poised her pen over it. “Serious final comments, anything else I should know? Once we’ve signed this, it’s done.”
Lucy swallowed. “Do it.”
Ruth scrawled her signature across the space, did the same on a second copy, then offered the pen so Lucy could do the same. Finally, she handed one over and tucked the rest away. “Done. You’re clear to go back to being a proper curate, with a proper training incumbent, just as soon as the last bits of admin get sorted. Someone will be in touch to arrange your licensing, given the current situation I'll probably have Janice do it.”
A grin from Lucy. “It’s… a relief really. Knowing what’s happening. I’ll have all the moving stress later but… it’s just good to know. Thanks. For everything.”
“I’m always here for you, you have my email if it’s a quick query, or go through Tom - or his successor, when… they take over - if you want a meeting. Otherwise I’ll see you before your ordination. And maybe on Tuesday, and just generally anywhere in the diocese. But for now, take care, be kind to yourself, and may God bless you, Lucy. Shall we wrap up with a moment of prayer, and then I’ll show you out?”